A Suitable Boy by Vikram Seth is a mammoth of a book, both in size and content. It is nearly 1400 pages long and weaves the stories of four families in post-independent India. The main storyline is that of Lata and her mother's quest to find a suitable boy for her to wed. Lata's suitors are Kabir (fellow student and successful player on the university cricket team), Amit (an in-law and a poet) and Haresh (shoe businessman and mom's choice for marriage).
I read this book twice. The first time I picked up the book was when I was in university and struggling to find myself within the identities of my culture, my race, my family and my interests. The second time was a few years after marriage, with a home to manage. About 12 years apart, and a lot had happened to me to change my circumstances and perspectives on life, which also influenced how I related to each suitor.
University me was carefree, impetuous and passionate. After the years of staying with my parents and having most decisions made for me, I loved my freedom to decide the who, what and where in my life. It was all about me, with minimal thought to culture, race and other socially defined boundaries. So I applied this same view to the Kabir / Amit / Haresh triangle. Lata's relationship with Kabir was juvenile love. They courted each other with shyness, and there were occasional medium gestures to make you feel like they took the feelings seriously. However, it was apparent that Kabir was committed to cricket and his medical career, and he wanted to deal with the relationship complications by just winging it. Even me, in my coconut craving haze, could see that it was not a long term love. Good first love though!
I adored Amit from the start. I found him to be mature, witty, funny and sensitive enough to not be arrogant. I loved the riposte in the Chatterji family, especially between Amit and Kuku. So when Amit had feelings for Lata, in my mind, he was a perfect catch. His poem to her was subtle but so very passionate, and I was swooning every step of the way, on Lata's behalf.
Haresh came across as ambitious, determined and a little square. He fit the description of the perfect arranged marriage, which was what Mrs Mehra was after, but lacked the charm and vitality that the other characters had. His moments of love were not magnificent declarations, but rather straightforward letters, which to me was just plain boring. Haresh was the one to cliff, the one who was there to show Lata that there were better options.
So I was furious with the ending! I could not figure out why Lata made her decision for an arranged marriage when she could have had love and hot romance!
Fast forward to the second time reading: I had an arranged marriage and fell pregnant after 2 years. I was semi-employed, living in a new country, far away from my immediate family and worrying about my mom, my dog, my life, my husband, my kids and my in-laws. This time around, I read through all the history bits and learnt more about the long term effects of the partition of India. I bristled that Maan could chase after a courtesan with very little repercussion but Lata suffered her mother's wrath when someone saw her talking to Kabir. (I felt more strongly about this because I have 2 girls and I want them to be equal in the world.)
Kabir was still an intense and shallow love interest for Lata. The romance developed because he payed attention to Lata, not necessarily because they communicated on a deep level. Definitely the one to cliff!
I still adored Amit, his one-liners and his kindness. He looked after Lata when she visited the family. She was comfortable in his company and probably felt extremely self-conscious when he would spontaneously reveal his feelings for her.
Now Haresh, on the other hand, was a changed man. He wanted to have a successful career in order to be married to anyone, even Lata. He was pragmatic in his approach to work, his romancing of Lata and his relationships with the people around him. While passionate love might not be high on his list of priorities, he had everything else covered - good social standing, got along with the family, steadfast and honest. Still square, but a square that you could work with. Now, although I still didn't fully agree with her choice, I understood why Lata married Haresh.